Bringing Advocacy Back-In: The Importance of Restoring the Advocacy Mandate of Immigrant Settlement Agencies

Nonprofits play two key roles in our society: delivering community services in partnership with the government and advocating for social change. Advocacy entails public education around pressing societal issues as well as direct lobbying of government to promote policies and programs for the public good. By amplifying the voices of marginalized communities, nonprofit advocacy strengthens democracy and challenges the dominance of powerful economic and political interests. Through advocacy, nonprofits foster citizenship building and social organization that is based on the values of independence, altruism, and collective action, ultimately advancing societal inclusion and cohesion. 

However, shifts in the political landscape have led to a decline in advocacy efforts across the nonprofit sector. In November, the K-Hub Lunch & Learn session welcomed Dr. John Shields, Professor Emeritus in the Department of Politics and Public Administration at the Toronto Metropolitan University, to speak on why Immigrant Settlement Agencies (ISA) must “bring advocacy back-in”. 

The Impact of Neoliberalism and New Public Management 

The erosion of advocacy in ISAs and other nonprofits can be traced back to the rise of neoliberalism in Canada in the 1970s. Emerging in response to the economic crisis, neoliberalism promoted the New Public Management (NPM) approach, which sought to “shrink the state” and provide market-driven solutions to societal issues. This shift led to the marketization of nonprofit work, where organizations became alternative service providers operating under strict government contracts, allowing the government to shift the risks and responsibilities onto individuals, families, and communities.  

As a result, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) now primarily funds, or underfunds, settlement services through projects, imposing rigid accountability measures, eligibility criteria, and performance targets. While this model has increased efficiency in service delivery, it has also significantly weakened nonprofits’ capacity, autonomy, and ability to advocate for systemic change.  

The Dichotomy of Precarity and Resilience 

This transformation has left ISAs navigating a difficult balance between precarity and resilience. Precarity refers to the uncertainty, instability, and heightened risk that nonprofits face due to chronic underfunding and reliance on short-term grants. Precarity extends to staff and clients alike, as job security and service availability become entirely dependent on the funding cycles. Over time, precarity has been normalized, imposing restructuring and austerity within the sector. 

Resilience in a neoliberal context, often translates to “doing more with less.” Nonprofits are expected to stretch resources, intensify workloads, and compete for limited funding to survive. This “everyday struggle” to stay afloat diminishes organizational capacity and energy and deepens social deficits. On the other hand, progressive resilience moves beyond mere survival- it fosters collaboration, challenges power relations, and promotes structural change such that the transformative potentials of individuals, communities, and social institutions are brought forward. 

ISAs and Advocacy 

Advocacy is a crucial component of progressive resilience. It enables ISAs to amplify client voices and push for systemic improvements. However, securing dedicated funding for advocacy remains a significant challenge. The government contracts rarely, if ever, support advocacy initiatives and strict regulations on nonprofit and registered charity status create fear of repercussions, reinforcing the belief that organizations must avoid “biting the hand that feeds them.”  

As a result, advocacy has not disappeared but has instead become intermittent, hybrid, and masked. While this approach allows nonprofits to influence policy behind the scenes, its effectiveness rests entirely on whether government officials and funders are willing to listen, respect, and engage with nonprofits as true partners. Unfortunately, the dominant neoliberal framework views ISAs primarily as service contractors, undermining and delegitimizing their role as advocates for systemic change. 

Dr. Shields pointed out that during the COVID-19 pandemic, a policy window briefly opened, emphasizing intersectoral collaboration. However, recent political shifts, including a rightward drift and growing anti-immigration rhetoric, suggest a resurgence of reinforced neoliberalism. Now, more than ever, nonprofit advocacy has become critical in countering these challenges and ensuring the sector’s collective voice remains strong. Restoring the advocacy mandate of ISAs requires urgent reflection and action. 

Check out the session recording above to hear more about advocacy and ISAs. For a comprehensive analysis of Canadian nonprofit sector and its evolving challenges, explore Dr. John Shields’s latest book, “The Canadian Non-profit Sector: Neoliberalism and the Assault on Community”. 

The Lunch & Learn series is a monthly virtual gathering hosted by the Newcomer Knowledge Hub. We provide informative presentations delivered by experts in the settlement sector. Whether you are a service provider, policymaker, student, or simply curious about the world of settlement, we invite you to join us at our next session by registering here. 


Posted

in

by

Comments

Leave a Reply