Establishing a Standardized Process for Obtaining Research Consent at a Sectoral Level

Our very first Lunch & Learn session, hosted by the Newcomer Knowledge Hub (K-Hub), was a resounding success, and we are thrilled to share the highlights with you! Today’s session,  “Establishing a Standardized Process for Obtaining Research Consent at a Sectoral Level,” was presented by Jeff Halvorsen, PhD CE, a Postdoctoral Scholar, and Megan Gill, BSW, RSW, a MITACS research intern at the K-Hub. Unfamiliar with research or consent? You are not alone. Information collection occurs at various levels within settlement services, therefore understanding informed consent is crucial for providing ethical services to our clients.  

Informed Consent in Practice 

In practical settings, informed consent is guided by professional bodies such as the Canadian Association of Social Workers (CASW), or by legislation such as Alberta’s Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (FOIPP) and Personal Information Protection Act (PIPA), and federal Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA). Confidentiality, the right to make choices, safeguarding welfare, and limiting collection are some common themes in the practice context.  

Historical Context of Research Ethics 

Historically, research ethics have had dark chapters, such as the Milgram Experiment or the Tuskegee Syphilis Study. Fortunately in modern-day Canada, ethical guidelines such as Tri-Council Policy Statement prioritizes the autonomy and welfare of the participants and underscores our duty to treat people fairly and equitably.  

Informed Consent in the Community 

Community-level context has its own challenges. Indigenous communities have been subjected to phrenology, ethnographic observations, and other racist sciences that sought to justify colonization. Since then, the community’s efforts to maintain traditional ways of knowing were codified in the United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP). Principles like Ownership, Control, Access and Possession (OCAP) ensures that First Nations communities have control over the research processes and have ownership over their own data. 

A study conducted by Neufeld et al. (2019) in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, a heavily researched community, found that ethical research should emphasize reciprocity, be trauma-informed, involve participants in interpretations, and provide ongoing consent. McLaughlin and Alfaro-Velcamp (2015) highlighted the vulnerabilities of newcomer population in research. These include unfamiliarity with the legal systems in the host country, their perception of researchers as authority figures, and the risk of their detention and deportation. While conducting research with newcomer population, it is recommended that the research protocol is reviewed by an immigrant status expert.  

Informed Consent in Settlement Agencies 

In April 2023, the K-Hub research team conducted a focus group study with the Dynamic Collaborative, a group of practitioners, academics, funders, and policymakers, to explore how informed consent could be integrated into settlement services. If you are interested in learning more about the Dynamic Collaborative and other publications by K-Hub, you can find them here! 

The Dynamic Collaborative discussed that it is crucial to have robust data policies that clearly outlines who can share data and for what purpose, safeguards around the secondary use of data, and data masking techniques to protect the client confidentiality. Clear communication of risks and benefits is also essential. This means full transparency in sharing the research purpose and the confidentiality process with the clients and ensuring clients understand they can withdraw consent at any time. 

Another theme identified by the group was that of inclusion and justice. Simplifying the language of consent forms to ensure clarity and ease of understanding once they are translated to clients’ preferred language, recognizing cultural differences in understanding the concept of research and consent. Another suggestion was to involve clients in study design to empower them and to foster collaboration for meaningful outcomes. (Did you know that K-Hub has a research advisory council of newcomers with lived settlement experiences? Click here to read about our latest research advisory council). Lastly, separating services and research consent by differentiating the timing of consent helps clients understand they can receive services without consenting to research. 

The Lunch & Learn series is a monthly virtual gathering hosted by the Newcomer Knowledge Hub. We provide informative presentations delivered by experts in the settlement sector. Whether you are a service provider, policymaker, student, or simply curious about the world of settlement, we invite you to join us at our next session. Click here to become a part of our Southern Albertan network of passionate professionals! 


Posted

in

by

Comments

Leave a Reply